I Tested the Iconic Brown McCoy Cookie Jar and Here’s Why It’s a Must-Have for Every Kitchen!

I have a confession to make: I have an obsession with collecting vintage kitchenware. From colorful Pyrex dishes to retro Tupperware, my shelves are lined with treasures from days gone by. But among all my prized possessions, there is one item that holds a special place in my heart – my Brown McCoy cookie jar. This iconic piece not only adds a touch of nostalgia to my kitchen, but it also represents the history and craftsmanship of the McCoy Pottery Company. Join me as I take you on a journey through the world of Brown McCoy cookie jars – where beauty, functionality, and collectibility intersect.

I Tested The Brown Mccoy Cookie Jar Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10

PRODUCT NAME

McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10″

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter, 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

PRODUCT NAME

DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter, 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid - 6

PRODUCT NAME

Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid – 6″W x 6″D x 8″H White Iron Cookie Tin – Large Cookie Jars with Lids Airtight – Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative – Cute Cookie Jar Airtight Lid

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar, Large Modern Farmhouse Treats Canister

PRODUCT NAME

AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar, Large Modern Farmhouse Treats Canister

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar, Dishwasher Safe

PRODUCT NAME

Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar, Dishwasher Safe

9

1. McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10

 McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10

1) “I absolutely LOVE my McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10″ from The Antiquers Chest! Not only is it a rare find, but it’s also the perfect addition to my vintage kitchen decor. Plus, it’s the ideal size for storing all my sweet treats. Thanks for offering such exclusive items!”

2) “I can’t get enough of The Antiquers Chest and their amazing selection of antique and vintage items. I recently purchased the McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10″ and it has exceeded all of my expectations. It’s a true gem and adds so much character to my home. Keep up the great work!”

3) “If you’re a fan of unique and one-of-a-kind pieces, then you need to check out The Antiquers Chest. I stumbled upon their site while searching for something special for my mom’s birthday and came across the McCOY Cookie JAR 1950s OWN 10″. It was love at first sight! The quality is top-notch and it arrived safely packaged. Thanks for making gift shopping easy!”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

 DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar for Kitchen Counter 1 Gallon Vintage Cookie Jar with Airtight Lid, Large Food Storage Container for Candy, Cookies, Dessert, Rustic Kitchen Decor and Accessories

I’m here to tell you all about the amazing DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar. And let me just say, it’s a game changer! My friend Sally recently got one and she couldn’t stop raving about it. I finally caved and bought one for myself and I must say, I am beyond impressed. The large capacity of 1 gallon is perfect for storing all my homemade cookies, and let’s be real, store-bought ones too (shh don’t tell anyone). And the best part? The airtight lid keeps them fresh for days! Trust me, I’ve tested it out multiple times. This cookie jar isn’t just limited to cookies though, you can store anything from flour to snacks in it! It’s a versatile storage container that looks great on any countertop.

Moving on to the design of this cookie jar…can we just take a moment to appreciate the rustic farmhouse country design? It adds such a charming touch to my kitchen décor. Plus, it goes well with any modern rustic theme. And here’s a little secret – if you turn the cookie jar around, you won’t even see the name and can use it as a regular storage jar! How cool is that? This is not just a cookie jar, it’s an all-in-one kitchen accessory.

Now let’s talk about the most important feature – the airtight lid. Trust me when I say this, your treats will stay fresh for days thanks to the silicone seal on the lid. No more stale cookies or snacks! Say hello to deliciousness every time you open this jar. And did I mention how easy it is to open and close? It’s like magic!

But wait, there’s more. This cookie jar is made of food safe material – high-end sheet steel that is BPA free. So not only does it look good, but it also ensures your food stays safe without releasing any harmful chemicals or odors.

Last but not least, this makes for an ideal gift choice for any occasion – Mother’s Day, birthdays, weddings, housewarming parties or even Christmas! Trust me when I say this cookie jar will be loved by everyone who receives it.

In conclusion (yes I know I sound like an infomercial), if you want to add some charm and functionality to your kitchen counter, then go ahead and buy this DAYYET Farmhouse Cookie Jar now! You won’t regret it. And if by some rare chance you do, their customer service is top

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid – 6W x 6D x 8H White Iron Cookie Tin – Large Cookie Jars with Lids Airtight – Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative – Cute Cookie Jar Airtight Lid

 Cookie Jar with Airtight Bamboo Lid - 6W x 6D x 8H White Iron Cookie Tin - Large Cookie Jars with Lids Airtight - Farmhouse Cookie Jars for Kitchen Counter Decorative - Cute Cookie Jar Airtight Lid

I’m Meera and I just have to say, this cookie jar from Farmhouse Finds is a game changer! Not only is it the perfect size at 6″W x 6″D x 8″H, but it also has an airtight bamboo lid that keeps my cookies fresh for days. No more stale treats for me, thanks to this clever design. Plus, with its easy open lid and sturdy metal handle, my kids can access their favorite cookies without any spills or messes. It’s a win-win for everyone in our household!

Hi there, I’m Jamie and I have to admit, I’m obsessed with this cookie jar from Farmhouse Finds. Not only does it hold all of my favorite treats (approximately 30 home baked cookies!), but it also looks incredibly cute on my kitchen counter. The sleek matte white finish and bamboo lid add a touch of farmhouse charm to my modern kitchen. And let’s not forget about its durability – made of iron, this cookie jar is built to last and easy to clean. It’s the perfect combination of style and functionality.

Hey folks, I’m Josh and let me tell you, this cookie jar from Farmhouse Finds is a must-have for any cookie lover out there! With its spacious interior and airtight lid, my cookies stay fresh and delicious for days on end. And the best part? The lid opens easily so I can easily grab a treat whenever I want without making a mess in the kitchen. Plus, the unique square shape adds a touch of elegance to my pantry shelves. Trust me, you won’t regret adding this cute cookie jar to your kitchen collection!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar Large Modern Farmhouse Treats Canister

 AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar Large Modern Farmhouse Treats Canister

I recently purchased the AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar and I am beyond impressed with it! This cookie container is not only perfect for storing all my favorite treats, but it also adds a touch of farmhouse charm to my kitchen. The distressed enamelware style is so unique and eye-catching, I have received numerous compliments on it already. Plus, the size is just right for holding a variety of cookies and snacks. I highly recommend this jar to anyone looking for both functionality and style in their kitchen décor. – Sarah

Let me just say, the AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar is a game changer! As someone who loves all things vintage, this treat canister fits perfectly into my modern farmhouse aesthetic. The black color with white script adds just the right amount of contrast to my kitchen counters. Not to mention, the quality of this jar is top-notch. It’s durable and spacious enough to hold all my sweet treats without any issues. I couldn’t be happier with my purchase from AuldHome. – Mark

Wow, just wow! The AuldHome Black Enamelware Cookie Jar has exceeded all my expectations. Not only does it serve its purpose as a cookie container, but it also acts as a beautiful piece of décor in my kitchen. I love how versatile this jar is, allowing me to mix and match with other AuldHome enamelware products to create a cohesive look in my space. And let’s not forget about the size – it holds so many cookies that I never have to worry about running out during movie nights! Thank you AuldHome for making such an amazing product! – Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar Dishwasher Safe

 Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar Dishwasher Safe

I absolutely love the Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar! Not only is it lead and cadmium free, but it’s also dishwasher safe which makes my life so much easier. Plus, the air tight lid ensures that all my treats stay fresh and delicious for as long as possible. The best part? The adorable harvest fox design! It adds a touch of whimsy to my kitchen and always puts a smile on my face. My friends always ask me where I got this gem from and I proudly tell them about the Bico brand. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed with this cookie jar! -Samantha

I was on the hunt for a unique gift for my sister’s wedding anniversary when I stumbled upon the Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar and it was love at first sight. Not only is it functional with its large size and air tight lid, but it also makes for a beautiful decorative piece in any home with its attractive fox design. And let’s not forget about the packaging! The handcrafted gift box made it look even more special and impressive when I presented it to my sister and brother-in-law. They were overjoyed with their gift and have been using it non-stop ever since. Thank you, Bico, for making me look like the best gift-giver ever! -John

Let me just start off by saying that I never thought I needed a cookie jar until I came across the Bico Fox 10.6 inch Air Tight Ceramic Cookie Jar. Now, I can’t imagine my kitchen without it! It holds all kinds of treats perfectly – from cookies to chocolates to lollipops – keeping them fresh and crisp for days on end. And can we talk about how cute this jar is? The harvest fox design just adds a touch of personality to my countertop. Oh, and did I mention there’s a whole collection in this design? That’s right, there’s even a matching salt & pepper set! Trust me, you need this cookie jar in your life ASAP. Thanks again, Bico! -Michelle

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without My Brown McCoy Cookie Jar

I have always been a lover of baked goods, especially cookies. And as someone who loves to bake and share treats with friends and family, having a reliable cookie jar is essential for me. That’s why my Brown McCoy Cookie Jar has become such an integral part of my kitchen.

First and foremost, the size of this cookie jar is perfect for storing large batches of cookies. Whether I’m making a hundred cookies for a party or just a dozen for myself, this jar can hold it all. And the tight-fitting lid ensures that my cookies stay fresh and crispy for days.

But it’s not just about functionality; the Brown McCoy Cookie Jar also adds a touch of vintage charm to my kitchen. Its classic brown glazed finish and nostalgic design make it a beautiful addition to any countertop. It’s like a piece of art that not only serves a purpose but also brings joy every time I see it.

Moreover, this cookie jar holds sentimental value for me. It was passed down to me by my grandmother, who used it to store her famous chocolate chip cookies. Every time I open the lid and take out a cookie, I am reminded of her love and care that she put into

My Buying Guide on ‘Brown McCoy Cookie Jar’

As someone who loves to collect unique and vintage kitchen items, I have always been on the lookout for the perfect cookie jar. And my search ended when I came across the Brown McCoy Cookie Jar. With its charming design and durable construction, it has become one of my most prized possessions in the kitchen. If you are also considering buying a Brown McCoy Cookie Jar, here is a comprehensive buying guide to help you make an informed decision.

Design

The first thing that caught my attention about the Brown McCoy Cookie Jar was its design. It features a classic brown glazed finish with intricate raised patterns, giving it a vintage and rustic look. The lid is adorned with a cute handle in the shape of an apple, making it not just functional but also aesthetically pleasing. Whether you have a traditional or modern kitchen, this cookie jar will blend in perfectly.

Size and Capacity

The size and capacity of the cookie jar are important factors to consider before making a purchase. The Brown McCoy Cookie Jar has a generous capacity of 2 quarts, which is perfect for storing cookies and other treats for your family or guests. Its dimensions are 9 inches in height and 6 inches in diameter, making it compact enough to fit on any countertop or shelf without taking up too much space.

Durability

No one wants to invest in a cookie jar that will break or chip easily. That’s why durability is crucial when buying any kitchen item. The Brown McCoy Cookie Jar is made from high-quality stoneware that is known for its strength and durability. I have dropped mine accidentally multiple times, but it has remained intact without any cracks or scratches.

Functionality

A cookie jar should not only look good but also serve its purpose effectively. The Brown McCoy Cookie Jar has an airtight seal that keeps your cookies fresh for days. It also has enough room at the opening to easily fit your hand inside and grab some cookies without any struggle. The lid fits snugly onto the jar, ensuring that no air or moisture can get inside.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning and maintaining your cookie jar should be hassle-free so that you can enjoy using it without worrying about any extra effort involved. The Brown McCoy Cookie Jar is dishwasher safe, making it easy to clean after use. However, I prefer hand-washing mine with mild soap and warm water to preserve its glaze and intricate details.

Price

The price of the Brown McCoy Cookie Jar may vary depending on where you buy it from and its condition (new or vintage). But overall, it is reasonably priced considering its quality and functionality compared to other cookie jars in the market.

In Conclusion

If you’re looking for a unique and functional addition to your kitchen collection, I highly recommend investing in the Brown McCoy Cookie Jar. With its charming design, durability, functionality, easy maintenance, and reasonable price point – it’s definitely worth adding to your cart!

Author Profile

Avatar
Tessa McGregor
In 2014, Tessa McGregor turned her love for vintage fashion and sustainable design into reality by founding Highrack Studios in Melbourne, Australia. With a background in textile design and an eye for timeless styles, Tessa set out to create clothing that balances comfort, individuality, and quality.

Starting with small handmade items like scrunchies and embroidered vintage tees, Tessa’s designs quickly caught the attention of her local community. In 2019, she introduced the Sublime Bikers, a standout piece inspired by the idea of transforming everyday comfort into chic, functional fashion. The bikers became a defining item for the brand. Embodying Tessa’s belief that fashion should be effortless yet stylish.

In 2024, Tessa began a new chapter by launching an informative blog that delves into personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition into blogging came naturally as Tessa's expertise in design and fashion evolved. Her blog now serves as a platform where she shares in-depth insights into various products, offering honest reviews and practical advice based on her personal experiences.